For a long time, if you wanted visibility, you had to rely on top athletes. Whether in the stadium, in traditional media or on social media, prominent faces guaranteed attention. But this understanding falls short in today's sports marketing. The decisive factors are no longer just reach and popularity, but relevance, authenticity and cultural connectivity with the target group.
The PRophet study"Athletes as Ambassadors" analyzes the brand impact of four globally renowned athletes and shows how the impact mechanisms of sponsorship have fundamentally changed. For communications managers, this creates a new strategic playing field: if you want more than mere presence, you have to focus on real fit and sustainable impact.
For the study, international online and social media posts as well as fan interactions were analyzed over a period of twelve months. It was supplemented by a six-month detailed analysis of the respective target groups. The focus is on four personalities from world sport, some of whom differ significantly in terms of style, impact and brand loyalty: Formula 1 champion Lewis Hamilton (brand ambassador for UNICEF and Dior), charismatic ex-football star David Beckham with commitments to UNICEF and adidas, tennis legend Serena Williams sponsored by UNICEF and Nike, and Simone Biles, world-class gymnast and face of sports fashion brand Athleta and Friends of the Children. Their individual profiles exemplify what works and what doesn't in new generation sponsorship.
Want to be the first to find out the latest insights from the sports industry?
Then subscribe to our free newsletter now and always be one step ahead.
Spot on? Only when attitude and target group fit together
The study reveals an uncomfortable truth: the media presence of athletes in itself does not activate a brand. Rather, the decisive factor is whether the athlete and brand fit together credibly, communicate shared values and create relevant narratives, memorable and, above all, coherent images in the overall context.
An example: Lewis Hamilton is at the forefront of sport. 24 race weekends, countless headlines, a huge fan base. But only a fraction of his media presence is brand-related. Only 0.6% of his content is related to his sponsor, the fashion house Dior. This is a clear indicator of a structural problem: high visibility without strategic linkage harbors the risk that the communicative effect will fail to materialize.
David Beckham shows that it can be done differently and, above all, how. The former soccer star achieved the highest impact value in the study with significantly less content. Around 1.9 percent of his content is linked to his long-standing sponsor adidas. More than any other athlete in the study. The reason: Beckham links his various commitments, including as a UNICEF ambassador, with strong brand values such as integrity, consistency and social responsibility.
Tennis legend Serena Williams also makes it clear how individual moments can have a big impact. Her Nike commercial on motherhood became a cultural reference point for many fans and at times achieved a brand-related visibility of 3.05 percent. Far beyond the tennis world. Olympic prodigy Simone Biles, on the other hand, remains weak in terms of brand loyalty despite high sporting attention: Only 0.04 percent of her media presence can be linked to sponsor Athleta.
Attitude Compass 2025: How values shape brand identity and business success
The narrative as a success factor
But what exactly do Beckham and Williams do differently? What is striking is that successful sponsorship is not based on mere celebrity, but on narrative consistency. The brand message must fit organically into the athlete's story. This means: through career progression, attitude and social positioning. It's about attitude instead of hashtags. Serena Williams exemplifies this new quality. Her message of empowerment and equality is not contrived, but anchored in her biography. Nike succeeds in credibly picking up on this attitude and carrying it forward. The result: high authenticity, strong identification, measurable impact.
David Beckham uses his standing as a legend of world soccer not just for retro glamor, but for targeted communication of values. His commitment to social justice in particular makes him a long-term and credible reputation anchor for UNICEF and adidas.
And Lewis Hamilton? He may embody the modern winner image, but despite his obvious penchant for fashion and exclusivity, he lacks a connection to content. His community is primarily interested in motorsport and performance. For Dior, a luxury brand with no sporting DNA, this is a difficult match.
Simone Biles moved millions with her courage to speak openly about mental health. But this resonance had no effect on the brand impact of her sponsors. A strategic deficit that limits relevance and reach.
Authentic sponsorship: Jana Kesenheimer's learnings for the sports industry
Relevance arises from a comparison with the audience
Authentic messages are only fully effective if they reach the right target group. Reach without relevance therefore remains strategically limited. If you want to create brand loyalty, you not only have to communicate credibly, but also precisely define who you actually want to reach. It is also important to regularly check whether this is successful. PRophet has segmented follower groups in the media analysis and examined their interests, value profiles and media behavior. The result: a differentiated target group picture and clear recommendations for the targeting of future campaigns.
Hamilton primarily reaches communities with an affinity for motorsport: performance-oriented, male-dominated and clearly structured. This target group is considered loyal, but is less receptive to fashion or lifestyle narratives. Serena Williams, on the other hand, appeals to a culturally diverse audience that is socially interested, predominantly female and open to topics such as inclusion and empowerment.
Beckham's fanbase unites soccer fans, charity supporters and groups with an interest in pop culture. Sporting goods manufacturer adidas benefits here from an intersection of brand affinity and nostalgic attachment. Simone Biles' fan structure is highly emotionalized, but her sponsors are only visible to a limited extent.
Brands achieve impact above all when they see athletes not just as advertising space, but as credible identification figures with social relevance. This requires more than just media budgets. Strategic sensitivity, a sound understanding of the target group and the will to tell stories that are not only visible but also create trust are crucial. Because brand loyalty is created where values resonate and relevance endures.
Finding sponsors: 5 tips for the path to partnership
Want to know what authentic sponsorship looks like in practice?
SPORT BRAND MEDIA by ESB Marketingnetzwerk is the industry summit for everyone who wants to know more about the strategic combination of sports, brands and media. Get exclusive insights from leading brands, sports organizations and media experts who are shaping the future of sports marketing. The conference offers the ideal opportunity for exchange between media, sponsors, suppliers, service providers and start-ups. The conference takes place on 01 and 02 DEC. at ISPO 2025 in Munich - be there!